England’s bid to reach a first World Cup final since 1966 came to an agonising end as they lost in extra time to Croatia in Moscow.

Juventus striker Mario Mandzukic scored the winning goal in the 109th minute of the semi-final, slotting in from Ivan Perisic’s flick-on into the area.

England – in their first World Cup semi-final since they were beaten on penalties by West Germany at Italia ’90 – were given the perfect start through Kieran Trippier’s 20-yard free-kick after only five minutes, but Perisic’s 68th-minute equaliser sent the match into extra time.

England’s players were inconsolable at the final whistle as the dream was snatched away and the pain was etched on their faces as well as that of manager Gareth Southgate – but they can take great pride and credit from this tournament.

Croatia, in sharp contrast, were jubilant and will now face France in the final in Moscow on Sunday.

Unfancied before the competition, England defied expectations by reaching the semi-finals, but were undone by an experienced Croatia side.

Harry Kane’s golden touch deserted him when he missed a great chance to double their lead, and Jesse Lingard also wasted a chance by shooting wide.

As England allowed their opportunity to slip from their grasp, Croatia grew in confidence.

England lost momentum after the break and were punished when Perisic stole in ahead of Kyle Walker for an athletic finish.

Croatia, with Luka Modric the orchestrator, took control as England faded, with Perisic hitting the post and Jordan Pickford saving magnificently from Mandzukic, before the striker made the decisive contribution with 11 minutes of extra time left.

The 32-year-old reacted quicker than John Stones in the area to beat Pickford – and England had nothing left to give.

England will now play Belgium in Saturday’s third/fourth place play-off in St Petersburg.

England’s pride and pain

England’s disappointment at seeing their hopes come crashing down when they were so close to a place they have not inhabited for 52 years will be made more acute by the sense of missed opportunity.

They controlled the first half and, with Croatia initially looking out of sorts after going through the physical demands of extra time and penalties in their two previous games, England will know they could have settled this game in that crucial phase.

Instead, Croatia grew in stature and by the end it was Zlatko Dalic’s side who carried the greater energy and threat while England ran out of steam.

England’s expectation had reached fever pitch and they will regret their failure to take advantage of that spell when they were in control.

There was nothing that could offer solace to Southgate and England’s players as they stood saluting their supporters at the end – but the reaction from the travelling fans was an indicator of what they achieved in Russia.

England’s fans rose as one to give them a standing ovation in a show of appreciation for their best run at a major competition since Euro ’96 – and a far cry from the humiliation of failing to get out of the group stage in Brazil four years ago and the Euro 2016 elimination by minnows Iceland in the last 16.

Southgate and his players have conducted themselves superbly and offered enough to take renewed optimism into the next phase of England’s development.

One game too far?

England’s loss to Croatia looked like a case of one game too far for a squad that has given so much over the course of a long Premier League season and here in Russia.

It should be stressed that Croatia’s effort was magnificent given their exertions in the past two knockout rounds – but England looked like a spent force as this game went on.

Kane gave it everything but the sharpness was not there, removing a crucial threat as they searched for the spark to reignite their World Cup ambitions.

Dele Alli also looked short of full power after a bright start, as did Lingard, and even the introduction of Marcus Rashford could not fire up England.

England looked ready to run riot in the first half, with Sterling outstanding, but they were flat from the start of the second period, allowing Croatia to get up a head of steam that in the end proved unstoppable.

Southgate must now rouse his players against Belgium in St Petersburg on Saturday – a tough task given the scale of their disappointment and the raw emotion of this bitter loss.

England’s next step

England will leave Russia after their final match on Saturday with their reputation on the highest stage restored after the embarrassment of recent years.

Southgate has grown into the job and has been outstanding here, while players such as Pickford, Harry Maguire and the brilliant Trippier have acquired new respect for their deeds and enhanced their profiles.

England have been given an identity by a group of players who reflect the modest, mature approach of their manager and in a style of play Southgate has developed and insists will serve them well in the future.

Most observers regarded a quarter-final as a respectable outcome in Russia, so to reach the last four is to be lauded.

There can be no disguising that the draw offered England an opportunity to reach a World Cup final that they just didn’t have the power to take – the future, however, is bright and full of hope.

‘Broken through barriers’

England manager Gareth Southgate: “At the moment we all feel the pain of defeat. I don’t think realistically we expected to be here, but once you’re here and played as well as we did, you want to take those opportunities in life. The dressing room is a difficult place at the moment.

“I’m remarkably proud of the group of players – the reaction of the supporters compared to two years ago shows the country are proud of the way we played. There will in time be lots of positives to take but it’s too hard and too soon to put that in context.

“You have to suffer the result first sometimes. I’m hugely proud of what we’ve done – I couldn’t have asked for any more. They’ve broken through a number of barriers in the past weeks.”

Set-piece specialists – the stats

• England have been eliminated in four of their five semi-finals at major tournaments, losing each of the past four they have reached – Euro 1968 v Yugoslavia, World Cup 1990 v West Germany, Euro 1996 v Germany and World Cup 2018 v Croatia.
• Croatia have qualified for their first World Cup final in their fifth appearance at the tournament.
• England have lost three competitive games against Croatia since the turn of the Millennium, more than any against any other nation.
• Mandzukic’s winning goal was the latest goal ever conceded by England in a World Cup match – 108 minutes, three seconds.
• Trippier became the first player to score a direct free-kick for England at the World Cup since David Beckham in 2006 against Ecuador.
• Perisic has been involved in 10 goals at major tournaments for Croatia (six goals, four assists), the joint-most, level with Davor Suker (nine goals, one assist).
• Trippier’s goal after four minutes and 44 seconds was the fastest goal scored in a World Cup semi-final since 1958 (Vava after two minutes for Brazil v France).
• Croatia became the first team to play extra time in three consecutive World Cup matches since England in 1990.
• England scored nine goals from set-pieces at the 2018 World Cup – the most by a team in a single World Cup tournament since 1966.
• Four of the five 2018 World Cup matches to go to extra time have involved either England or Croatia (the other was Spain v Russia).